Scoop by Scoop: The Enchanting Journey of Gelato from Florence to the World
- Nico Gleason
- May 24, 2023
- 5 min read

First invented in the 16th century, gelato has become a world-renowned sweet treat. Though the details surrounding the birth of gelato aren't fully known, the most popular story claims that a Florence native named Bernardo Buontalenti created the first form of modern gelato in the 16th century.
History
Bernardo Buontalenti, born in Florence in 1531 and passing away in 1608, was a highly talented individual who excelled in various fields such as architecture, theatrical design, military engineering, and art. Renowned for his skills as a mechanic and mathematician, Buontalenti is traditionally credited as the first inventor of gelato. His innovative mind and creative spirit paved the way for the development of this beloved frozen dessert. With his contributions, gelato has evolved into a cherished culinary delight enjoyed by people worldwide.
Though the true origin of modern gelato is not precisely known, one of the most popular and widely accepted versions of its creation story attributes it to a man named Bernardo Buontalenti in the 16th century. According to this account, the Grand Duke Cosimo I de’ Medici tasked Buontalenti with organizing a lavish banquet to honor the Spanish deputation. In response, Buontalenti ingeniously invented a new dessert for the occasion—an exquisite frozen cream. This delicacy was crafted using a combination of ice, salt (to lower the temperature), lemon, sugar, eggs, honey, milk, and a touch of wine.
Buontalenti

Buontalenti is a gelato flavor named after Bernardo Buontalenti, who is widely credited for the creation of gelato. This particular flavor is crafted using a combination of milk, sugar, cream, and eggs, along with some undisclosed secret ingredients. The intention behind this flavor is to replicate the taste of the gelato that Buontalenti created for the esteemed Grand Duke Cosimo I de' Medici during the 16th century.
Today, there is an abundance of gelato shops scattered across the globe, solidifying its status as an Italian culinary staple. It is a common sight to witness individuals strolling through the streets of Italy, happily indulging in a cone or cup of this delectable frozen treat. The popularity of gelato has transcended borders, captivating the hearts (and taste buds) of people worldwide. Its irresistible allure lies in the rich and creamy texture, coupled with an extensive array of flavors to suit every preference. Whether savoring the timeless classics or exploring innovative and exotic combinations, the experience of enjoying gelato is a cherished part of Italian culture that continues to delight locals and visitors alike.
Gelaterias
La Carraia in Santa Croce is a beloved local gelateria situated in Florence, Italy, right next to the Santa Croce. Since 1990, the dedicated owners of La Carraia have been steadfast in their mission to interpret and showcase the flavors of the ancient Florentine tradition with utmost excellence. Their commitment to quality and authenticity shines through in every scoop of gelato they serve. Stepping into La Carraia is like embarking on a delightful journey of taste, where you can relish the true essence of Florentine flavors.

Francesco Tolotta, an employee at La Carraia, says he always suggests “something creamy and sweet” to those visiting the gelateria. It's no surprise that lines form daily outside the doors of La Carraia, as people eagerly await their turn to sample the two most popular flavors in all of Italy: pistachio and stracciatella. These classic favorites have captured the hearts and palates of gelato enthusiasts, drawing them to this renowned establishment in Florence. The combination of the rich and nutty pistachio flavor and the delicate chocolate shavings in the luscious stracciatella gelato is simply irresistible. La Carraia's commitment to quality and their ability to satisfy the cravings of gelato lovers have made them a cherished destination for locals and tourists alike.
With a multitude of possibilities for mixing and matching different gelato flavors, Tolotta is always able to guarantee satisfaction to his customers. “Trust me, you'll love it” has almost become a catchphrase for him as any combination of flavors always has customers coming back wanting more.
One such delighted visitor is Estephanie Gonzales, who is currently visiting Florence from Cuba. She enthusiastically shares, "This is my second cup today! The multitude of flavors and the endless combinations keep me coming back for more." Estephanie's experience exemplifies the allure of gelato, as its tantalizing variety entices individuals to explore and savor the unique taste sensations offered by each scoop.

The delightful gelato experience extends beyond the gelaterias of Florence. In Pisa, Italy, La Bottega del Gelato stands proudly as the oldest gelato shop in the city. This charming establishment upholds the tradition of homemade gelato, which is often distinguished by being stored under a metal lid. La Bottega del Gelato remains faithful to this practice, ensuring that their gelato maintains its authentic flavor and quality.

With their slogan being "Il gelato è felicità condensata," which translates to "Ice cream is happiness condensed," La Bottega del Gelato invites visitors to indulge in the sheer joy and bliss that a scoop of their gelato brings.
Gelato has evolved into more than just a sweet treat; it has transformed into a pseudo-sport, where gelato makers compete for the prestigious title of "World Champion." Gelateria Dondoli in San Gimignano, Italy, stands as a shining example of the incredible success that comes with such a title. This renowned gelato shop was crowned the Gelato World Champion from 2006/2007 to 2008/2009, solidifying its reputation as a destination not to be missed.
The popularity of Gelateria Dondoli is evident from the perpetual line stretching out the door and weaving through the plaza. This humble little shop has captivated the hearts and palates of gelato enthusiasts from all over the world. Here, customers can indulge in a wide array of flavors, ranging from the unconventional, such as white wine and rosemary, to the timeless classics like pistachio and stracciatella. Each spoonful is a taste of perfection, crafted with meticulous attention to detail and a passion for delivering an unforgettable gelato experience.
Gelaterias throughout Italy

A journey through Italy is incomplete without indulging in the delightful world of gelato. From its mysterious origins in the 16th century, credited to the ingenious Bernardo Buontalenti, to the present-day gelaterias that grace the streets of Florence, Pisa, and beyond, gelato has become an iconic symbol of Italian culinary excellence. The passion and artistry of gelato makers are evident in the wide array of flavors and combinations they offer, catering to every palate and leaving visitors craving for more. Whether you find yourself savoring a creamy scoop of pistachio or a refreshing serving of stracciatella, the taste of gelato transcends mere ice cream—it is a decadent experience that encapsulates the very essence of happiness. So, as you embark on your Italian adventure, be sure to treat yourself to this frozen delight and allow the flavors of gelato to transport you to a realm of pure bliss.
Comments